Marissa Hayes is a technical editor and contributing writer. She holds a Bachelor’s Degree in history, and she was the editor of the literary magazine, The Bluestone Review.

Full Bio →

Written by

Dan Walker graduated with a BS in Administrative Management in 2005 and has been working in his family’s insurance agency, FCI Agency, for 15 years. He is licensed as an agent to write property and casualty insurance, including home, auto, umbrella, and dwelling fire insurance. He’s also been featured on sites like

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Daniel Walker
Licensed Car Insurance Agent Daniel Walker

UPDATED: Feb 22, 2022

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

Insurantly Evaluates Used Cars Under $10,000

choices for used cars under 10000

One of the most common sentiments consumer have when looking to buy a used car under $10,000 is making sure the value is there for the money. Buying a reliable car that will not break down and then require extraordinary maintenance is always key when trying to save money and be smart about how long it will last.

If there were a buyer’s list that had goals for vehicles under 10k those might be somewhere at the top.  As an added bonus if you have repair shops and good selections of parts, this will make servicing the vehicle much easier.

Although the secondary market is the obvious choice for most consumers, in recent years issues with used cars have steadily increased. For example it’s not uncommon to find a used car with altered mileage. Carfax calls this “Odemeter fraud” stated in an article written in 2012.  Bottom line if the used car has to good to be true mileage make sure you ask further questions and verify as much as possible.

What is Considered Good Value?

value for the money

Did you know that a new car depreciates by as much as 27% after the first year? What prevents a dramatic depreciation drop are top notch reviews from experts and the market’s appreciation of the car.

With regards to cheaper or lower cost used cars under 10k here is what good value may refer to:

  • Good value refers to a reliable car that will not require extraordinary and possibly expensive repairs.
  • Further, having available parts and qualified technicians as well as dependable repair shops conveniently close by also ads value to the used car.

Fortunately, for a car shopper with a budget of $10,000 there are a number of excellent makes and models in the market from luxury to conservative sedans, family cars, or sporty vehicles, and even hybrid used cars all can be found for under $10,000.  Other factors that you may consider part of your criteria are fuel efficiency and the peripheral costs like insurance, which can impact over 10% of your vehicle costs.

What are the top brands for used cars under $10,000?

Ideally, it would be fantastic to buy a used European car brand because European brands are considered as heavyweights in the auto industry. Practically speaking though, many of the European cars require regular maintenance and careful driving. The replacement parts are also more expensive than American or Asian brands.

Many consumers lean towards Japanese brands like Toyota, Honda or Hyundai because these brands have some of the best fuel efficient used cars under $10,000 with excellent resale value.

The Ford Focus 2010

ford focus 2010 can be purchased for under 10k

For an American used car under $10,000 the 2009 to 2011 Ford Focus now sells for around $6,000.

It is a fun car, possibly one of the best cars for college students, especially if the first owner bought the optional Sync infotainment system.

Best SUVs Under $10,000

Japanese brands Subaru, Honda, Toyota, and Mitsubishi offer some of the best used AWD  under $10,000. For people who enjoy road trips or live in areas where the weather can turn harsh, the AWD (4 wheel drive) are excellent options particularly especially if they have a good ground clearance.

When you pick a used AWD SUV, you might consider the following factors:

  • Center of gravity
  • Suspension specs
  • Road grip
  • And the road conditions

With these factors handily addressed, you won’t have to be burdened with increased insurance costs because you will have addressed some of the critical safety issues most car insurance companies have with AWD SUVs. AWD is more a performance characteristic you the consumer desire but doesn’t necessarily make the vehicle safer.

Hondo CRV 2002 to 2008

used CRV's under 10k

The older Honda CR-V models are touted to be better quality than the later models and one of them is the 2005 model. It has been voted as one of the best small SUVs with its ample space and height, 4 cylinder engine, low cargo floor, and high level of reliable service.

The most admired features of the CR-V are the fuel efficiency, practicality, and maneuverability. It also has optional AWD and replacement parts are easy to find.

Toyota 4Runner 2004 to 2008

Toyota 4Runner under 10000

The 4Runner is a popular choice as a used SUV under $10,000. It looks great, can easily go off-road with high ground clearance, is very reliable with minimal issues, cheap replacement parts, and has a 4.7 V8 or 4.0 V6 with up to 270 horsepower.

Provided you follow a strict maintenance system, you will not be blown off by its fuel consumption.

The Mitsubishi Outlander 2007

Mitsubishi Outlander 2007

This affordable SUV is a midsize SUV equipped with either a 4 cylinder or V6 engine. It has good balance and easy handling although the 4 cylinder may not as comfortable because of its smaller tires.  It is considered as one of the best commuter and one of the best family cars under $10,000.

According to consumer reports for used cars under $10,000, reliability of the Outlander is exemplary and with an original sticker price of $21,270, getting it for under $10,000 is a steal. Other SUVs of similar specs sold for an average of almost $30,000 sticker price.

The horsepower of the Outlander is 220 but you still get excellent mileage of 17 MPG for city driving and 25 MPG for highway runs. Consumers who have purchased this vehicle have stated how impressed they were by its acceleration, which is 4.8% faster.

Best Used Family Cars Under $10,000

Family cars are either SUVs or sedans. The best used family SUV cars under $10,000 are listed above. As for the sedans, there is a good selection of like the Mazda 3 (2008), Pontiac Vibe, Acura TL (2005), Acura TSX (2005), Toyota Avalon (2005), Toyota Corolla (2006, 2010), and Infiniti G35 (2010).

There are other used cars that can qualify as a reliable choice. The ultimate decision would depend on the current and your expected family size over the next 2 years.

Mazda 3 2008

This could be the best used small size family car under $10,000. It’s responsive, comfortable, has an excellent interior with an overall mileage of 25 MPG. The original sticker price for this car was $18,385. It has a 2.3 liter inline 4 engine with 5 speed automatic transmission, 156 HP, and a torque of 150 ft-lbs.

Pontiac Vibe 2005 to 2008

This wagon with AWD is efficient and reliable with a roomy interior and storage compartment. The main problem with the Pontiac is the slight wiggling but you can fix this by buying the stability control unless the seller has already had it installed.

The wagon tends to be slower because of a higher than average power to weight ratio of 21.4 lbs/HP but it is lighter than most compact hatchbacks at only 2,700 pounds.

Whether you want a used conservative family car, an SUV, sports, hybrid or luxury car, there are ways to protect your investment so you don’t end up with a lemon or a car that’s constantly being dragged to the shop for repairs.

  • If you want the best sports car, best luxury or hybrid car under $10,000, do not buy from a vendor who deals with cars that have been turned over several times. Stick to first owner. This way you won’t have problems tracking its history, receipts, and documents.
  • It is important to put reliability above cost or first impressions. Unless you know cars very well, when you go for the test drive, be sure to bring an expert along. This person should be experienced in listening for the odd sounds that would tell the true tale of the vehicle’s condition.
  • Do determine the history of the car especially with regards maintenance and address of owner. Since flooding has been more frequent of late in some areas around the country, look for telltale signs of water damage.

Finally, used cars under $10,000 are plentiful but watch out for aesthetic cover-ups. If you run a magnet over the body, you can detect bodywork repairs and aside from looking at the mileage, look for signs of wear and tear.

A used car bought for under $10,000 may cost you less in insurance because the rule of thumb is to charge a lower rate for older models but you can lower this rate even more if you buy a model and make that has a good road record in terms of number of crashes, recalls, and positive feedback.

Car Insurance costs on Used cars and SUVs

A good thing about used cars is that quite often you don’t need full coverage. A solid liability plan with an affordable deductible might be all you need. Talk to your insurance agent about this option as it could save you quite a bit on your monthly payment.  Read Insurantly’s liability FAQ page to learn more.

Another factor mentioned earlier on this page was in regards to safety options and replacement parts. Safety is key with insurance companies. Its keeps things like injuries and total damage costs down thus reducing claims.

If you are considering a used car or SUV make sure you thoroughly evaluate and discuss how each option might price out with your agent.

Other tips on used cars and SUVs

Some cars seem to be stolen more than others. And some areas of country certain vehicles are stolen more than other makes and models. Check these lists nearest you so that you do not pay a higher rate. Insurance companies consider the rate of car theft as a rate factor so just because you are buying used does not exempt you from higher auto insurance costs.

Tip: Find an affordable option by installing an anti-theft device given if it fits into your budget.

You will save money by making sure that you only buy coverage that is right for you

Check your state laws to make sure you get enough coverage as you may only need the minimums. However, it is worth exploring pros and cons of additional liability coverage if you have assets to protect. Again speak with an experienced insurance agent.

Most consumers are not aware that the maximum you can get from full and collision is the value of your car. Deciding to buy these options could be worth the additional cost.

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

How much is car insurance on a used car or SUV?

Let Insurantly help you compare auto insurance on any type of vehicle. Insurantly will match you with a live auto insurance agent to help you find the lowest rates in your area.