Marissa Hayes

Insurance Writer & Expert

Marissa Hayes is a technical editor and contributing writer. She holds a Bachelor’s Degree in history, and she was the editor of the literary magazine, The Bluestone Review.

Insurance Writer & Expert

Daniel Walker

Licensed Insurance Agent

Daniel Walker graduated with a BS in Administrative Management in 2005 and has run his family’s insurance agency, FCI Agency, for over 15 years (BBB A+). He is licensed as an insurance agent to write property and casualty insurance, including home, life, auto, umbrella, and dwelling fire insurance. He’s also been featured on sites like and Safeco. To ensure our content is accura...

Licensed Insurance Agent

UPDATED: Mar 21, 2024

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

Now and again consumers create false impressions that a higher price tag equals higher value. When it is time to compare auto insurance providers, many people can be led to believe that better coverage and exceptional customer service automatically come at a higher price.

If this is you, rest assured that there are what many consumers consider the best car insurance companies that deliver an excellent experience and great products, while keeping your wallet at ease, too.

Falling into the trap of thinking that cheap cost means cheap value is easy to do, especially when you’re trying to protect an investment as important and expensive as your car.

When it comes time to Compare rates it may also seem like an overwhelming process, and if you’re not completely sure what you’re looking for or what else is out there, you may still end up coming out on the short end of the process (and the paycheck).
Start your auto insurance quote online by entering your zip code now.

Competing rates from these and 32 of the most diverse companies

All State vs. State Farm Car Insurance Comparison

Two of the highly visible insurance companies in the country are Allstate and State Farm.  They were established 9 years apart with State Farm in 1922 and Allstate in 1931. Another trivia about these two companies is that their headquarters are both based in Illinois.

Read more: Best Car Insurance in Your State

The General Car Insurance

The General is another very popular auto insurance company. However they cater to the secondary market for people with bad driving records considered more high risk.

SafeAuto Car Insurance

SafeAuto car insurance is another popular company that does a lot of its business online. There are definitely some things a consumer should read first before deciding on a policy. Overall the company has very good ratings.

Geico vs. Progressive Car Insurance Comparison

Geico and Progressive are probably more visible with their commercials and sponsorships than any other insurance company. See how Insurantly compares these two very popular carriers.

Read more:

Mercury Car Insurance

Mercury Car Insurance is based in California and majority of its policies are underwritten in this state.

21st Century Car Insurance

Did you know that 21st century is under the farmers insurance umbrella? Learn how 21st century might be right for you. (For more information, read our “21st Century Auto Insurance“).

Direct Auto Insurance

Direct Auto Insurance based in Tennessee is part of the Direct General Corporation. Direct Auto acts as a broker being that the company is a holding company and works with independent insurance agents.

Infinity Auto Insurance

Infinity Property & Casualty Corporation in Alabama, also known as Infinity Auto Insurance, is an auto insurance provider. They focus on nonstandard car insurance and has well over 12,000 independent agents.

Read more: Alabama Auto Insurance

Acceptance Auto Insurance

Acceptance auto insurance is a personal auto insurer with headquarters in Tennessee and more than 350 neighborhood offices in about 12 Midwest and South states. They also cater to the non standard high risk market.

Advice to find top rated auto insurance companies that are affordable to your budget while fitting your needs:

For starters, you’ll want to start in a spot that you may not even know exists. If you’re like many people, you probably don’t even realize that each state has a Department of Insurance.

What do you do with this website once you’ve found it? Harness the power of the consumer complaints data to find out what your neighbors think. What kind of experiences have they had?

Just because a company has a big marketing budget that has been designed to make you feel safe and secure, nor does it mean they will actually deliver on those promises. Knowing how your neighbor’s experiences went with certain companies will help you make a more educated decision.

Consider what’s important to you. In this age of having all information available at your fingertips, you may not realize how much you rely on things like mobile apps for your insurance company.

Some of the largest carriers are able to provide you conveniences that other companies haven’t quite caught up to because of their online platforms or user interfaces. If it’s important for you to be able to access an app or have access to a customer service representative around the clock, make sure you keep this in mind from the beginning of your car insurance journey.

Report cards aren’t just for fifth graders. Make sure you review your potential companies’ own report cards. J.D. Power, A.M. Best, and Standard and Poor’s are excellent resources for determining where a company stands amongst its peers.

When you compare top car insurance companies, look for companies that values its reputation of trust with drivers and body shops. Take a look at the “report cards” to see how companies are rated with customer service, claims processing, and overall satisfaction.

Take only what you need. You’ve heard this from your parents and teachers for your whole life. At some point, we have to admit that those people may have been on to something. When it comes to your automobile, cheap liability insurance may be the best way to go for people with both stellar credit, as well as those struggling to rebuild their credit rating.

If you have a brand new car, you’ll likely want to protect it to the highest ability that you can. However, many people are over-insuring their cars. Meaning, if your car is paid off and aging, you might want to consider lowering your costs by implementing liability coverage.

Ask the car insurance company about discounts. Everyone likes a discount. Insurance companies offer many different discounts to their customers. The trick is they don’t always tell you about them so you have to ask.

Combine your renters / homeowners insurance with your auto policy. This will give you an extra discount and help ensure your rate is a little cheaper. Car insurance companies offer many types of discounts such as good driver, discounts for students, and taking road safety tests for safe driving all driving conditions. Speak to your insurance agent or company.

8 Tips On Choosing The Best Auto Insurance Companies

  • Figure out how much coverage you need
  • Check your current policy
  • Check driving record
  • Compare rates
  • Gather information
  • Look for discounts
  • Cancel policy after you review and approved
  • Are you buying a new car and new to auto insurance?

No matter what your reason for seeking a more affordable policy, money matters but so does having the appropriate coverage. Finding the cheapest rates that still fits all your needs is the key. So use some of these tips that Insurantly provides that ensures safe travel for you, your family, and your passengers.

First question to ask yourself is how much auto insurance coverage do you really need? Just about every state requires you to at least carry liability insurance coverage of which will include bodily injury and property damage in the event you are at fault in an accident. Other states will require you to purchase things like personal injury protection and uninsured motorists coverage.

More questions about your car insurance polity? See our FAQ page.

Top High Risk Car Insurance Companies

Unfortunately people obtain a bad driving record for whatever reason. Tickets, accidents, multiple claims, your age – young drivers, your credit, type of car, where you live, DUI/DWI driving under the influence of alcohol to name some of the top items will land you in high risk court with car insurance companies. (For more information, read our “Auto Insurance Companies That Accept Drivers With Multiple Accidents“).

Insurantly can help you find the best high risk auto insurance company no matter your situation. To learn more see our high risk car insurance page. There you will be able to compare top rated high risk carriers.